The El Nino Election
You just received the latest polling data for the your boss, the Mayor of Malibu. Unfortunately for you and the Mayor, it looks like you may both need to find a new source of income after the upcoming election. It seems the people of Malibu feel as though their Mayor has lost touch with the people and their most basic needs. As the Mayor's press secretary, it is your duty to make the Mayor look good and provide for him/her every opportunity to shine in the eyes of his/her constituents. As you search for anything positive to raise ratings, you come across an article in the newspaper related to the weather phenomenon, El Nino. According to the report your city is again going to be at the mercy of Mother Nature. For many this news is awful, for you it means an answer to prayer.
After getting the Mayor's ear, you outline your plan to boost his ratings and secure another victory in the upcoming election. You explain the concept of an El Nino Election, an idea that if worked properly will allow the Mayor to take an active role in saving the lives and property in this majestic community. Through the auspices of the Mayor's office, you are going to arrange a task force made up of prominent city leaders and officers. The task force will include the City Manager, the President of the Chamber of Commerce, the leader of the Citizens Patrol team and, of course, you.
After contacting everyone individually and securing agreements, you arrange a press conference for the Mayor to announce his intentions. Through proper planning and the Mayor's guidance, a plan is going to be formulated by the aforementioned people that will guide the citizens of Malibu through the upcoming El Nino winter. Before you get too excited it would be important to remember that you haven't done anything yet, and the important questions do not yet have answers.
Your job begins this way,
Your team is assigned the task of researching and generating as much useful information as possible on El Nino for both the Mayor and the citizens of Malibu. You should do this in a professional manner keeping in mind that your actions can and will have a lasting effect on the city and its people. Your research should address the questions raised by the Mayor and when you are done, you need to prepare written recommendations so that the mayor can effectively lead his citizens through this potentially catastrophic event.
Try to stay within this framework:
A. Determine which of you is going to assume each identity. (Chamber President, Press Secretary, Citizens Patrol and City Manager)
B. Divide the research questions among you based on their applicability to your job. Don't be afraid to allow questions to overlap as each of you may be able to answer the same question but in a different way.
C. When finished with your findings, share them with each other and put together a package of information that best answers the Mayor's questions and provides an effective level of preparedness for the citizens of Malibu.
D. Lastly, be prepared to present your information in a variety of ways to the Mayor. It is important that you do this because the citizens of Malibu are a diverse group and all have different levels of access to information. What may work for some may not work for all but all need to get the information.
World Wide Web Sites
National Weather Service Los Angeles/Oxnard
Malibu Chamber of Commerce
NOAA El Nino Site
USA TODAY El Nino Site
Federal Emergency Management Association
City of Malibu(Government)
It is important for you to remember that your job is to support the Mayor as well as provide needed information to the town's people. Your failure to do so could result in the loss of life, property and the Mayor's job. While the phenomenon known as El Nino cannot be accurately predicted, you would be wise to prepare the citizens of Malibu for the worst and hope for the best. You are looking for solutions regarding a general lack of information. Knowledge is power and your job is to make people powerful.
You and your team will be evaluated on the thoroughness of your research, the quality of your recommendations, and the organization of your presentation to the Mayor.
This activity is designed to raise awareness about the decision making process that goes on every day in our local city governments. In light of what you have learned about the city of Malibu, how might El Nino effect your community. What steps have been taken in your town in preparation for severe weather or other natural disasters. On a more personal level it would be wise to consider just what you and your family have planned as a response to mother nature. We often fall into the trap of 20/20 hindsight where we plan to succeed only after we failed to plan. Don't be in a position waiting for your city to help you, first be ready to help yourself.
Spend a moment considering the work you have just completed. Then pick one of the following questions to answer and write a short response as part of your evaluation.
1. If you were the Mayor of your city, what would you do to make your town safer in the event of a natural disaster?
2. Consider your surrounding environment. In what way might you harness the power of an El Nino for the betterment of your community?
Length of Lesson
2-3 weeks depending on how involved you want students to become. If you assign e-mail as a component you will have to allow extra time, since the students can't control the outcome.
Students become involved in the decision-making dynamics of city government where decisions can cost money, lives and votes.
H/SS Content Standards 12.7
5. How public policy is formed, including the setting of the public agenda and how it is carried out through regulations and executive orders
Students describe and evaluate the means that citizens use to monitor and influence the public agenda and decision making of government institutes through such means as voting, campaigning, lobbying, filing a legal challenge, etc.
Research, Evidence and Point of View
4. Students construct and test hypotheses; collect, evaluate and employ information from multiple primary and secondary sources; and apply it in oral and written presentations.
Language Arts Grade 12: Listening and Speaking: Students formulate adroit judgments about oral communication. They deliver focused and coherent presentations of their own that convey clear and distinct perspectives and solid reasoning. They incorporate gestures, tone, and vocabulary tailored to audience and purpose.
This lesson is designed for the students to take an active role in their learning and to make decisions within their groups. It is designed for groups of four and for the groups to decide amongst themselves the duties and tasks. If for some reason the students express a difficulty in doing this you can assign the duties in this way:
- 1. Citizens Group- Devise a FAQ, provide local storm watch information
- 2. City Manager- Identify potential storm problems, outline solutions
- 3. Chamber President- Examine economic impact disseminating information
- 4. Press Secretary- Determine emergency procedures, liaison for Mayor
With the help of your class, you should devise a rubric to help shape the lesson and its completion. This will help to guide the students and keep them on task.
Internet access is a must, and access to email for students is recommended but not required.
The lesson intertwines with Language Arts and Science as the students are asked to research a variety of materials.
Adaptations for Special Needs Students
- 1. Expand the size of your groups to allow for more cooperation amongst team members.
- 2. Allow for more time so that all students have sufficient use of the resources.
- 3. Modify sections of the lesson as necessary to fit the needs of the students.
David R. Mac Donald
Michael S. Karayan
Fillmore Middle School Fillmore USD